November 17, 2026 · Food and Beverages
FDA Preventive Controls Warning Letters: A 21 CFR 117 Checklist for Canadian Food Exporters
By Mussarat Fatima

If your company makes food in Canada and ships it to the United States, there is a federal rule that can stop your product at the border and put your name in a public warning letter: 21 CFR Part 117, the United States Food and Drug Administration rule on Current Good Manufacturing Practice, Hazard Analysis, and Risk-Based Preventive Controls for Human Food. In the second half of 2026, the FDA Human Foods Program posted a run of warning letters against food makers that got the basics of this rule wrong, including two California facilities whose failures map directly onto problems common in Canadian plants. This guide explains what 21 CFR 117 requires, who has to comply, and how to build a food safety plan that holds up, with a practical checklist drawn from the actual 2026 findings.
Every regulation, section number and warning letter detail below has been verified against the primary FDA and eCFR sources. Where a claim could not be confirmed from a primary source, it is not stated as fact.
Executive summary
What is 21 CFR 117 and who must comply?
The rule came out of the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act. Its structure is worth knowing because FDA warning letters cite specific sections, and knowing which subpart a citation sits in tells you what went wrong. Part 117 runs from section 117.1 to 117.475 and is organised into seven subparts.
| Subpart | Title | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| A | General Provisions | Scope, definitions, exemptions, qualifications of individuals |
| B | Current Good Manufacturing Practice | Sanitation, plant and grounds, equipment, personnel, process controls (the CGMP baseline) |
| C | Hazard Analysis and Risk-Based Preventive Controls | The food safety plan, hazard analysis, preventive controls, monitoring, corrective actions, verification, recall plan, PCQI |
| D | Modified Requirements | Reduced requirements for qualified facilities and certain storage facilities |
| E | Withdrawal of a Qualified Facility Exemption | How FDA can remove a qualified facility exemption |
| F | Records | Records that must be established and maintained, retention and official review |
| G | Supply-Chain Program | Controlling hazards in raw materials and ingredients through supplier approval and verification |
Two points matter for Canadian exporters. First, this is a United States rule that applies to your Canadian facility if you must register with FDA, and FDA does inspect foreign facilities. Second, it sits alongside, and does not replace, your Canadian Safe Food for Canadians preventive control plan. The good news is that the thinking is the same. A plant that runs a disciplined preventive control plan at home is most of the way to a compliant 21 CFR 117 food safety plan, provided it closes the United States specific gaps.
The food safety plan and the PCQI
The section numbers in Subpart C are the ones you will see quoted in FDA correspondence. Learn them, because an auditor who says you failed 117.130 is telling you your hazard analysis was the problem, while a reference to 117.135 points at your preventive controls. The table below lists the core elements.
| Section | Element | What FDA expects |
|---|---|---|
| 117.126 | Food safety plan | A written plan covering all required elements, overseen by a PCQI |
| 117.130 | Hazard analysis | Identify and evaluate known or reasonably foreseeable biological, chemical and physical hazards for each product |
| 117.135 | Preventive controls | Process, food allergen, sanitation and supply-chain controls, plus others as needed, to significantly minimize or prevent hazards |
| 117.139 | Recall plan | A written recall plan for any hazard requiring a preventive control |
| 117.140 to 117.145 | Management and monitoring | Monitoring, with written procedures and records that controls are working |
| 117.150 | Corrective actions and corrections | What you do when a control fails or a problem is found |
| 117.155 to 117.165 | Verification and validation | Validate controls work, verify they are implemented and effective, including product and environmental testing as appropriate |
| 117.170 | Reanalysis | Reanalyse the plan at least every three years or when conditions change |
| 117.180 | PCQI and qualified auditor | A qualified person oversees the plan and performs or oversees key activities |
Lesson one: the hazard analysis is where most failures start
The most common and most damaging error in the 2026 letters was not a broken control. It was a hazard analysis that failed to identify a hazard in the first place. If a hazard is not on the list, no control is built for it, and the gap runs through the whole plan.
La Cabana Food Distributing: environmental pathogens left off the list
In a warning letter dated 29 July 2026, FDA cited La Cabana Food Distributing, an Oceanside, California maker of ready-to-eat cooked salsa and uncooked sauce, under 21 CFR 117.130(a)(1). The firm's hazard analysis for refrigerated cooked salsa listed the biological hazard as none identified, and did not identify environmental pathogens as a hazard requiring a preventive control. FDA found Listeria monocytogenes on non-food-contact surfaces in the plant during the inspection. For a ready-to-eat product exposed to the environment after a kill step, an environmental pathogen like Listeria is a known or reasonably foreseeable hazard, and leaving it off the hazard analysis is a serious finding. FDA concluded the food was adulterated within the meaning of section 402(a)(4) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act.
Initiative Foods: a chemical hazard the plan rated too low
In a warning letter dated 29 September 2026, FDA cited IF Co-Pack doing business as Initiative Foods, a Sanger, California maker of fruit and vegetable baby food including puree pouches, under 21 CFR 117.130(a)(1). For acidified and high-acid fruit and vegetable pouches, the firm did not identify patulin, a mycotoxin associated with mouldy apples, as a hazard requiring a preventive control, rating it as having a low likelihood of occurrence. The context made that rating hard to defend: in February 2026 the firm had conducted a voluntary recall of an apple, pear and banana puree after a United States government sample, and its own private laboratory testing had detected patulin at 40 parts per billion in one lot. FDA also noted there was no documentation that incoming certificates of analysis were reviewed as part of a preventive control.
Lesson two: sanitation and preventive controls must be verified, not assumed
Identifying a hazard is only the first step. The preventive controls in 117.135, including sanitation controls, have to actually work, and you have to be able to show it. In the La Cabana letter, FDA cited the sanitation controls under 117.135(c)(3) and found that the environmental monitoring procedure did not name Listeria monocytogenes as a target organism, did not specify the tests or the laboratory, and was not being carried out in practice. The presence of Listeria monocytogenes in the facility, FDA wrote, demonstrated that the sanitation efforts had been inadequate. The firm's corrective action response did not show intensified cleaning or resampling, and key records such as the Listeria sampling map could not be found.
This is the gap between a written procedure and a working control. For ready-to-eat foods, an environmental monitoring program for Listeria is a core verification activity, and it has to be real: defined target organisms, defined sample sites including zones around the product, a named laboratory, a response plan when a result is positive, and records that prove the work was done. The same logic applies to Canadian plants making ready-to-eat products under an environmental monitoring and allergen control plan. A program that exists only on paper is a finding waiting to happen.
Lesson three: a certificate of analysis is not a supply-chain program
Subpart G requires a supply-chain program when a hazard in a raw material or ingredient is controlled by the supplier rather than at your facility. In the La Cabana letter, FDA cited the supply-chain requirements under 117.405(c) and 117.410(c). The firm's hazard analysis for uncooked sauce identified Salmonella in produce as a hazard controlled only by supplier certificates of analysis and incoming inspection, which FDA said did not provide adequate assurance that the hazard was significantly minimized or prevented. FDA also noted that the produce was received from a packinghouse, while the farms were the appropriate entities to consider for the control.
A certificate of analysis on its own is not supplier verification. A supply-chain program has to approve suppliers based on a hazard evaluation, define the verification activity that matches the risk, which for a serious hazard like Salmonella in a raw agricultural commodity usually means more than a document, and identify the entity that actually controls the hazard. Canadian exporters that also sell at home will recognise the same discipline in a supplier verification and raw material program built for low-moisture and high-risk ingredients.
How this connects to FSVP and your Canadian program
Many Canadian exporters first meet 21 CFR 117 through their United States importer's Foreign Supplier Verification Program. The two rules are distinct. 21 CFR 117 is your facility's obligation if you are a registered facility. FSVP is the United States importer's obligation to verify that you, the foreign supplier, produce food in compliance with United States standards. In practice, when FDA writes to an importer about FSVP, the importer turns to you for your hazard analysis, your preventive controls records and your supplier verification. A clean 21 CFR 117 food safety plan is therefore also the document that keeps your United States customers compliant and keeps your shelf space.
The same logic reaches your other United States obligations, from FSMA 204 traceability for foods on the Food Traceability List, to seafood HACCP under 21 CFR 123 for fish and fishery products, to the chemical hazard expectations in FDA guidance and the physical hazard and foreign material controls that mirror Canadian preventive control plan requirements. Treating these as one connected system, rather than separate projects, is what keeps a growing exporter out of the warning letter list.
21 CFR 117 compliance checklist for Canadian food exporters
Use this checklist to pressure test your food safety plan against the areas FDA is citing.
- Confirm whether your facility is required to register with FDA, and whether any exemption (such as a qualified facility) actually applies to you.
- Appoint a preventive controls qualified individual (PCQI) to prepare or oversee the written food safety plan.
- Review the hazard analysis for every product and confirm that biological, chemical and physical hazards are identified based on your product, process and your own testing and recall history.
- For ready-to-eat foods exposed after a kill step, confirm environmental pathogens such as Listeria monocytogenes are identified as hazards and controlled.
- Verify that each preventive control has written monitoring, corrective action and verification procedures, and that the records exist and are current.
- Run a real environmental monitoring program: defined target organisms, defined zones and sample sites, a named laboratory, a positive-result response plan, and retained records.
- Build a supply-chain program that approves suppliers on a hazard evaluation and uses verification activities matched to the risk, not certificates of analysis alone.
- Identify the entity that actually controls each supplier hazard, including the farm rather than only the packinghouse where relevant.
- Maintain a written recall plan for every hazard requiring a preventive control.
- Reanalyse the food safety plan at least every three years and whenever a process, supplier, product or new hazard information changes.
- Align your 21 CFR 117 plan with your Canadian preventive control plan and with your United States importer's FSVP needs so one evidence set serves both.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Marking a real hazard none identified. If your product class, your process or your own data points to a hazard, the hazard analysis must capture it. FDA cited both 2026 firms under the hazard analysis section.
- Relying on certificates of analysis for supplier control. A certificate is a data point, not a verified control. Serious raw material hazards usually need audits, testing or more.
- Treating environmental monitoring as paperwork. A program that does not name the organism, the sites and the laboratory, and that is not actually run, will not survive a finding of pathogen in the plant.
- Assuming FSVP covers you. FSVP is the importer's duty. It does not relieve your facility of its own 21 CFR 117 obligations, and the importer will lean on your records.
- Letting the plan go stale. A food safety plan that is not reanalysed after a process change, a new supplier or a recall is out of date, and an out-of-date plan is a finding.
- Confusing the Canadian and United States plans. The thinking overlaps, but the documents, section references and some expectations differ. Map them deliberately.
Frequently asked questions
Does 21 CFR 117 apply to a Canadian facility, or only to United States plants?
It applies to any facility required to register with FDA under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act that manufactures, processes, packs or holds human food for the United States market, including foreign facilities. A Canadian plant that is required to register and is not exempt must meet the Current Good Manufacturing Practice requirements and the preventive controls and supply-chain requirements, and FDA can inspect it.
What is the difference between 21 CFR 117 and FSVP?
21 CFR 117 is your facility's own preventive controls obligation. FSVP, the Foreign Supplier Verification Program, is the United States importer's obligation to verify that its foreign suppliers produce food under standards that meet United States requirements. They are separate rules, but your 21 CFR 117 records are usually what the importer relies on to meet FSVP.
Who can be a preventive controls qualified individual?
A PCQI is a person who has successfully completed training in the development and application of risk-based preventive controls at least equivalent to a standardized curriculum recognized by FDA, or who is otherwise qualified through job experience to develop and apply a food safety system. The PCQI prepares or oversees the food safety plan and key activities such as validation and reanalysis.
Do I need an environmental monitoring program?
If you make a ready-to-eat food that is exposed to the environment after a control such as cooking, and the product supports the growth of an environmental pathogen, an environmental monitoring program is a core verification activity for your sanitation preventive controls. The 2026 La Cabana letter turned in large part on an environmental monitoring program that was not real in practice.
Is a certificate of analysis enough for supplier verification?
Not on its own for a serious hazard. A supply-chain program approves suppliers based on a hazard evaluation and applies a verification activity appropriate to the risk. For a hazard such as Salmonella in a raw agricultural commodity, FDA has signalled that certificates of analysis and incoming inspection alone do not provide adequate assurance.
How often must the food safety plan be reviewed?
The plan must be reanalysed at least once every three years, and sooner whenever there is a significant change that could create a new hazard, when new information about a hazard emerges, when a control is found ineffective, or after an unanticipated food safety problem. A recall or a positive environmental result is a clear trigger for reanalysis.
How MFLRC can help
MF License and Regulatory Consultants helps Canadian food manufacturers build and defend the food safety systems that keep product moving into the United States. We work from the same primary FDA and eCFR sources cited above, so the plan you receive is grounded in the rule, not a template.
Our food safety services include 21 CFR 117 gap assessments against your current program, hazard analysis and food safety plan development with a qualified individual, supply-chain program design that goes beyond certificates of analysis, environmental monitoring program design for ready-to-eat facilities, sanitation and allergen control procedures, FSVP support packages for your United States importers, mock inspections and warning letter response, and alignment of your Canadian Safe Food for Canadians preventive control plan with your United States obligations. We also help with standard operating procedure development, corrective and preventive action systems, and validation.
Shipping food to the United States? Book a 21 CFR 117 gap assessment with MFLRC. We stress test your hazard analysis, supply-chain program and sanitation controls against the exact sections FDA is citing, and give you a prioritized plan to close the gaps.
Conclusion
The 2026 warning letters are a clear message to food exporters: FDA is pressing on the fundamentals of 21 CFR 117, and the failures that draw a letter are rarely exotic. A hazard left off the analysis, a sanitation control that exists only on paper, a supplier hazard covered by a certificate instead of a verified control. For Canadian manufacturers, the path is straightforward. Build a current hazard analysis that reflects your own data, make your preventive controls real and verifiable, run a supply-chain program that matches the risk, and keep the plan alive through reanalysis. Do that, and 21 CFR 117 stops being a border risk and becomes the document that protects your United States business.
Sources and references
- eCFR: 21 CFR Part 117, Current Good Manufacturing Practice, Hazard Analysis, and Risk-Based Preventive Controls for Human Food
- FDA: FSMA Final Rule for Preventive Controls for Human Food
- FDA Warning Letter: La Cabana Food Distributing, Inc. (29 July 2026)
- FDA Warning Letter: IF Co-Pack, LLC dba Initiative Foods (29 September 2026)
Downloadable Resource
21 CFR 117 Food Safety Plan Checklist for Canadian Exporters
A branded checklist to pressure test your hazard analysis, preventive controls, supply-chain program and environmental monitoring against the sections FDA cited in 2026.
File: MFLRC-21-CFR-117-Food-Safety-Checklist.pdf
Share with others
Tags
